• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

Why do birds mimic? (2 Viewers)

Rasmus Boegh

BF member
In Tambapata in Peru I heard a dog... high in the canopy of a rainforest! Obviously this was no dog, but instead a Crested Oropendola, surely one of the most amazing singers of the world.
But here goes: Why do birds mimic (other birds and sometimes even human sounds)? Has it been shown to have any importance in the chance of mating? - Or is it just "for the fun of it"?
 
Last edited:
Here ya go, an excerpt from Straight Dope:


In most birds, calls and songs are innate--that is, there is no learning involved. A young bird raised in isolation will produce its species' characteristic vocalizations without ever having heard them before. The ability to learn vocalizations, and therefore to imitate them, is limited to three groups of birds: the songbirds (or passerines), which make up about half of all birds; the parrots; and, rather surprisingly, the hummingbirds. Among the passerines there are mimics in many groups, such as the starlings (including the mynas), mimic-thrushes (including the well-known mockingbird), true thrushes, and lyrebirds.

Why exactly birds mimic sounds has long been a puzzle. Among parrots and perhaps other social species, mimicry of the call of the mate or of other members of the flock may help identify the members of the group and thus foster pair or group cohesion. When your pet parrot exclaims "Pretty bird!", it's probably because it views you as its mate, or at least another member of the flock.

But many birds mimic the calls of other species, and have been known to imitate such things as telephones, alarms, and chainsaws. Why? The best guess is that imitation is the easiest way to increase the repertoire of calls a given individual can make. And what's so good about having a big repertoire? There are several possible benefits: (1) A big repertoire can indicate to a female that a male has been around awhile and thus is a good survivor, with enough experience to be a suitable mate. (2) The response of a female or rival to a particular song is likely to decline after long repetition. Constantly changing songs may help to maintain interest in the listener. In fact, it is often species that sing continuously for long periods like the mockingbird that have the largest repertoires. (3) Changing songs could interfere with a rival's--or perhaps a predator's--ability to track the singer's wherabouts.

Given the fact that parrots and passerines have vocal learning and can be taught to talk, one wonders at what the capabilities of hummingbirds, which also have vocal learning, might be.
 
Thank You! Interesting reading.
As far as I know, hummingbirds sing for the same reasons as passerines; keep others away from their territory and to attract a mate... So, I would presume that hummers fit well in to the last three theories.
 
Last edited:
crispycreme said:
Here ya go, an excerpt from Straight Dope:
Given the fact that parrots and passerines have vocal learning and can be taught to talk, one wonders at what the capabilities of hummingbirds, which also have vocal learning, might be.
Corvids too!.
When I was young a friend had a "pet" Rook that lived free. It used to imitate my friends mother calling her kids in for meals amongst other things. You couldn't tell it was not the mother calling them. It used to follow them to school and wait for them coming out!.
It used to get very upset when we'd climb the Peartree and "help" it build a nest ( It didn't have a mate).
 
Warning! This thread is more than 21 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top