• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

Feeders Kill Hummingbirds? (1 Viewer)

Photographer Nick

Active member
I read in a bird feeding book that if you do not change the nectar at least every other day the sun will corrupt the nectar and cause it to infect the bird's mouth and eventuall kill it.

I just wanted to know if anyone has witnessed this.
 
I think such scary stories are part truth and part marketing, especially if they want you to buy commercial nectar. You don't want to let the nectar get cloudy, but if the nectar is bad, it will taste bad to the hummingbirds and they won't drink it. Try to be diligent about changing it twice a week or so, but it's not as if a flower's nectar is antiseptic. Don't worry that you'll find a pile of dead hummingbirds under your feeder.
 
I was told by the person at the bird shop back in Wisconsin that you should change the nectar at least once a week, maybe more often if the weather is extremely hot and humid. The reason is that the sugar solution breeds bacteria and mold, which is bad for the birds. But far from dying, they will probably simply avoid your feeder - it's probable that nectar turned bad tastes and smells funny to them. After all, we can detect bad food, and I'm sure they have very sensitive taste/smell.

What struck me was that you should probably buy the smallest possible feeder, because what's the point of filling up a big jar if you're going to have to throw it all away every week? This really burned me - I originally bought one with a good sized jar, and now I can never fill it, there's just no point.

I changed it once a week last summer in Wisconsin, and at times it was getting pretty hot up there - around 100F. The hummingbirds seemed very, very happy and kept coming back to the feeder on a regular basis.

Remember to clean the feeder every time you change the nectar. You can buy little brushes made for running through the holes they feed from, that's necessary because those points are probably where the mold/bacteria might be a problem - where the sugar and air come into contact. I didn't use soap, but simply rinsed out well with hot water, and everything seemed fine. I would wash properly with soap perhaps at the end of the season, but that's just a gut estimate.
 
Surely that may be different for hummingbirds, who eat pretty much exclusively by slurping stuff with their tongue, rather than by cracking seeds with their beak? A tongue is a highly sensitive organ, I wonder if anybody has studied a hummingbird's sense of taste?
 
Studies do show that Hummingbirds (and Parrots) can discern different types of sugars and their concentrations but like all birds they have many fewer tastebuds than mammals. I haven't been able to find a precise figure, but they are no exception to the general rule illustrated below:

Animal Total # of taste buds
------ ---------------------
Chicken 24
Bullfinch 46
Turtle Dove 54
Japanese quail 62
Pigeon 50-75
Starling 200
Mallard 375
Bat 800
Human 9,000
Pig 15,000
Rabbit 17,000
Catfish 100,000

Graham
 
Hi nick i dont know if you are talking about store bought nectar or home made i use homemade and i change it about twice a week the hummers still come and enjoy it but the best and the time i see the most of them is right after i change it. so it is probly false.
but idont know about store bought.
 
Warning! This thread is more than 18 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top