biking birder 2010
Well-known member
An email from Mark Ian Avery
My e-petition to ban driven grouse shooting has two more weeks to run - it closes when the Westminster parliament is dissolved on 30 March.
If you are one of the 21,000+ signatories of this e-petition then 'thank you!' - together we have helped shape the agenda on grouse shooting for the future. Maybe you could do one last thing and forward this email to anyone who you think might be interested in signing too (UK citizens only).
If you think that driven grouse shooting is wonderful, and a completely sustainable land use, then don't sign this e-petition.
If you support a ban but haven't signed yet, then time is running out - why not sign now?
If you think that it's a bit complicated and that there are good things and bad things about driven grouse shooting then you are right! That's what I think too. But I also think that the 'bads' (illegal killing of protected wildlife (especially birds of prey), damage to wildlife sites through over-burning (especially of blanket bogs), increased greenhouse gas emissions (soil erosion and peat loss), increased water bills (water treatment costs due to water discolouration) and increased home insurance (because of increased flood risk)) outweigh the 'goods'. The 'goods' are economic value (easily replaced by other land uses and very small in national terms anyway), more of some ground-nesting birds (true) and protection of the uplands from 'worse' land uses (true in the past, but now most grouse moors are in national parks and/or have other wildlife and landscape designations which protect them from afforestation, wind turbines etc.). So, yes, it is complicated but that doesn't mean that there isn't a right answer!
If you aren't keen on grouse moor management but think that there are other ways forward, eg vicarious liability or licensing, then you might be right. But signing this e-petition will make it more likely that a future government will do something, rather than nothing, on this issue.
So, have a think about it, and then please sign this e-petition to ban driven grouse shooting.
Many thanks
Mark
Dr Mark Avery
PS Here's another way to highlight the plight of the Hen Harrier - vote for it in this poll of the nation's favourite birds organised by David Lindo. What a great way to raise the bird's profile!
My e-petition to ban driven grouse shooting has two more weeks to run - it closes when the Westminster parliament is dissolved on 30 March.
If you are one of the 21,000+ signatories of this e-petition then 'thank you!' - together we have helped shape the agenda on grouse shooting for the future. Maybe you could do one last thing and forward this email to anyone who you think might be interested in signing too (UK citizens only).
If you think that driven grouse shooting is wonderful, and a completely sustainable land use, then don't sign this e-petition.
If you support a ban but haven't signed yet, then time is running out - why not sign now?
If you think that it's a bit complicated and that there are good things and bad things about driven grouse shooting then you are right! That's what I think too. But I also think that the 'bads' (illegal killing of protected wildlife (especially birds of prey), damage to wildlife sites through over-burning (especially of blanket bogs), increased greenhouse gas emissions (soil erosion and peat loss), increased water bills (water treatment costs due to water discolouration) and increased home insurance (because of increased flood risk)) outweigh the 'goods'. The 'goods' are economic value (easily replaced by other land uses and very small in national terms anyway), more of some ground-nesting birds (true) and protection of the uplands from 'worse' land uses (true in the past, but now most grouse moors are in national parks and/or have other wildlife and landscape designations which protect them from afforestation, wind turbines etc.). So, yes, it is complicated but that doesn't mean that there isn't a right answer!
If you aren't keen on grouse moor management but think that there are other ways forward, eg vicarious liability or licensing, then you might be right. But signing this e-petition will make it more likely that a future government will do something, rather than nothing, on this issue.
So, have a think about it, and then please sign this e-petition to ban driven grouse shooting.
Many thanks
Mark
Dr Mark Avery
PS Here's another way to highlight the plight of the Hen Harrier - vote for it in this poll of the nation's favourite birds organised by David Lindo. What a great way to raise the bird's profile!