-
Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.
Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Big Black Crow With Yellow Beak, Uk (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter jcstanley
- Start date
Welcome to Birdforum jcstanley, could your bird be a Rook with a stained beak? They are the size of a Carrion Crow, but have a straight, featherless beak that gets paler at the base with as it matures.
Sasquatch Fingers
International Man of Leisure
Not sure about range, but maybe a Chough?
I think most birders have heard reports of crows with yellow beaks. They have been discussed extensively on this forum in the past. No one ever provides a photo of such a bird, however, and the reports always seem to come from people who are not experienced birders. I do not know what you saw; if it really was a crow with a yellow beak that would be extraordinary. People on this forum are usually very good at coming up with answers to the questions posted here, but I guess I am just trying to warn you that in this case you may not get a satisfactory identification of the bird.
Andy Adcock
Worst person on Birdforum
It would have to be Alpine Chough with a yellow bill and there are none in the UK.
A
Dolly pops
New member
My wife and I both saw a crow with a yellow beak..... And all we can find is the alpine chough....
lockbreeze926
Well-known member
How about unusually dark Common Buzzard in bad light?
How about a crow with a french fries in the bill?
Southern Frogmouth
Well-known member
In the 1980s there was a report of a juvenile Chough, if my recollection is correct it was near Wraybury, so myself and friends decided to go and look for it as it wasn't far. I think before we got there we had heard it wasn't a Chough but we went to look anyway. It turned out to be a normal Jackdaw with a yellow bill, whether from staining or a genetic aberration we couldn't tell. Obviously from back then I don't have a photo but it was definitely a Jackdaw with a yellow bill so they do exist and I guess it might be possible in other species too but have no evidence of that.
Cheers
Roy
P.S. it definitely was not something in the bill - french fries or otherwise.
Cheers
Roy
P.S. it definitely was not something in the bill - french fries or otherwise.
Last edited:
Bismarck Honeyeater
Barely known member
It is very common for experienced birders to make mistaken identities, often corrected quickly, sometimes not quickly enough. 😉
For non-birders it is even easier to be misled by one feature or another and come to the wrong identification. No offence intended.
An example from Reddit recently:
For non-birders it is even easier to be misled by one feature or another and come to the wrong identification. No offence intended.
An example from Reddit recently:
Greyilocks
New member
I saw this today.
It was Jackdaw-sized, and there were Jackdaws on the same roof, and my son said this had a grey neck/head (I couldn't see the grey), yet it had a yellow beak. I guess it might have been a blackbird, though it seemed bigger.
www.birdforum.net
It was Jackdaw-sized, and there were Jackdaws on the same roof, and my son said this had a grey neck/head (I couldn't see the grey), yet it had a yellow beak. I guess it might have been a blackbird, though it seemed bigger.
Screenshot 2023-09-10 at 16.46.08.png
The same size as a Jackdaw, but with a yellow beak
www.birdforum.net
Last edited:
lockbreeze926
Well-known member
Could be a Starling.
birdboybowley
Well-known member.....apparently so ;)
Jackdaw with a chip (?) in its bill
Greyilocks
New member
I don't think so. It was quite a big bird. My dad said it was a crow, but we said it was a jackdaw, and I took a picture to zoom in, and show him it was a jackdaw. I thought the yellow beak would be a giveaway as to who was right, but it seems to have clouded things.
Greyilocks
New member
The beak looks kind of odd, and may indeed be a chip rather than a beak. I'll have to go back looking for it ...
Greyilocks
New member
I've looked very closely at the photo, and I think I can see its black beak, holding a chip. It looks like the angle and positioning of the chip was almost perfect. Thanks for all your feedback! 
Harrybongo
Now, approximately, 33.33% accurate on bird IDs 👍
👍 😂
Harrybongo
Now, approximately, 33.33% accurate on bird IDs 👍
Hi. A juvenile chough has a yellow /orange bill, so might be that?
Bewick
Well-known member
Think a chough would be a rarity over there...
Similar threads
