• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

Any point putting out niger seed? (1 Viewer)

My niger feeder was only visited by occasional Goldfinches this winter but for the past three weeks it has attracted a succession of Lesser Redpolls, Siskins and a few Goldfinches every day. Up to ten birds are present at a time. The location is Surrey, England.
 
On our hanging feeders we only really get sparrows and starlings, recently a couple of blue tits and long tail tits have turned up but who knows if they'll stay. Do you think there'd be any point in trying niger seed in one? We don't ever see the goldfinches or other finches that are always mentioned as the reason of putting them out.

We did try a sample feeder a few years ago and it wasn't touched, but it wasn't really out for very long before it got wet, so I don't know if it'd be a waste of money trying it again for longer with a better feeder, hoping for a different result.
You can try good quality sunflower seeds. Once the Goldfinches appear then try the niger seeds. It's never too late to put out seeds they will eventually arrive.
 
You can try good quality sunflower seeds. Once the Goldfinches appear then try the niger seeds. It's never too late to put out seeds they will eventually arrive.

I've put some sunflower seeds out since you said that but I'm still waiting for anything to show some interest. The starlings haven't even thrown them out! I'm suppose they will soon. The miseable weather hasn't helped :)
 
I've never had any success with niger seed. Goldfinches have always gone for the sunflower hearts, niger always got thrown away untouched after a while.
Sooooo, I purchased a small pre filled yellow niger seed feeder today. I expect it to remain untouched but holding out a very slim hope that the goldfinches will use it and maybe even bring a siskin or two along with them 😂
 
2 goldfinches ate a few seeds from the niger feeder before swapping back to sunflower hearts. Tenner well spent 😂
 
The perfect thread has fallen in my lap😍

I live in one of the thousands of soulless, new build concrete jungles that every person you speak to across the country absolutely detests! Myself included. The closest bushes and trees are on the edge of the estate which were already there before it was tarmacced and its wildlife friendly habitat destroyed.

So I couldn’t believe what I was seeing other day when I was walking back from the Aldi and a dozen or more goldfiches were flitting over the drainage ditch at the bottom of the road!!

In urban Derby it’s like having Golden eagles soaring about!

I’ve already got sunflower hearts out on a dish and will give niger seeds from a feeder a try! I might even try a sort of Hansel and Gretel type tactic of chucking some seed on the ground from the bushes near the drainage ditch leading back to my house!
 
Update. I now have anywhere between 4 and 14 goldfinches on my feeding station these days! I’ve had to buy additional feeders to give them all a chance of some nyger! They absolutely love it! I’m so happy!

Today when I was walking back from the shops I heard long tailed tits and gold rests in the trees at the top of the road so my next goal is to get them in the garden!

Suet feeder is apparently best for the tits. Anyone any idea how to attract goldcrest?
 
North Ayrshire, [Scotland] - always had 20 goldfinches on my (20-port yellow-topped) niger feeder, only dislodged by redpolls and siskins. There's always a giant 12-port sunflower heart feeder there too, which attracts them too (and blue, great and coal tits, a hawfinch, chaffinches, greenfinches, etc) and fat-balls for all the others. I recently discovered berry and buggy nibbles (suet nuggets) and they were favourites too, especially on the ground for blackbirds, thrushes etc. I'd a blackcap inside the sunflower heart feeder (cage) for several days last winter (they should be in Africa at that time, but are increasingly overwintering in Britain). Goldcrests I'd put a fat-ball in a deep conifer tree, maybe it will feast on microscopic insects attracted to the fat!
 
On our hanging feeders we only really get sparrows and starlings, recently a couple of blue tits and long tail tits have turned up but who knows if they'll stay. Do you think there'd be any point in trying niger seed in one? We don't ever see the goldfinches or other finches that are always mentioned as the reason of putting them out.

We did try a sample feeder a few years ago and it wasn't touched, but it wasn't really out for very long before it got wet, so I don't know if it'd be a waste of money trying it again for longer with a better feeder, hoping for a different result.
I inherited my parent's home and live in it. Several years ago, due to my health problems I cut down four large maple trees, the only maples in the yard. (Could not find anyone to pick up the huge volume of leaves.) I will regret it to the day I die. Very few birds anymore. ZERO Goldfinches. I put up bird feeders last spring. Put fresh nyger seed in tubular and mesh feeders for the entire spring and summer. Never attracted ANY birds. I recall my parents couldn't afford the nyger seen the gold finches ate. The birds need cover.
 
I inherited my parent's home and live in it. Several years ago, due to my health problems I cut down four large maple trees, the only maples in the yard. (Could not find anyone to pick up the huge volume of leaves.) I will regret it to the day I die. Very few birds anymore. ZERO Goldfinches. I put up bird feeders last spring. Put fresh nyger seed in tubular and mesh feeders for the entire spring and summer. Never attracted ANY birds. I recall my parents couldn't afford the nyger seen the gold finches ate. The birds need cover.
Too late for you now, but actually I just now came home from birdclub lecture - by master gardner and scientist - in which importance of leaving leaves was discussed. Birds eat mostly insects. Insects need ground detritus. Nuff'said!
 
...importance of leaving leaves was discussed. Birds eat mostly insects. Insects need ground detritus. Nuff'said!
I was at the time, still working full time, coming home to a foot of leaves in the back yard, and apples from the apple tree that had to be removed before the yard could be mowed.
 
On our hanging feeders we only really get sparrows and starlings, recently a couple of blue tits and long tail tits have turned up but who knows if they'll stay. Do you think there'd be any point in trying niger seed in one? We don't ever see the goldfinches or other finches that are always mentioned as the reason of putting them out.

We did try a sample feeder a few years ago and it wasn't touched, but it wasn't really out for very long before it got wet, so I don't know if it'd be a waste of money trying it again for longer with a better feeder, hoping for a different result.
I will send you half of my Lesser Goldfinch horde. They can clean me out of 20# of nyjer seed in 3-4 days, because they have big mouths and tell every other goldfinch in the city that they eat really well. They hang out gorging themselves at least 3x a day. I am surprised they can fly and haven’t broken the sock branches.
 
I had the metal top/bottom nyjer feeder with pierced plastic tube, and this was on the wall in the balcony of an apartment. What the goldfinches seemed to like were two things.
Peace and quiet - I had them a short distance away from the other feeders.
Able to queue (or fight) by having a platform on which they could perch. This was especially true once they started to bring their ultra-cute babies to feed. The babies would wait whilst screaming for food and doing this amazing little wiggle dance to indicate their hunger !!

I am currently looking for some old pictures I took and will post them here. Sadly the videos show this behaviour the best but we cannot post these here :-(
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top