Pipit ID Scotland (1 Viewer)

[Baldoon57]

These pictures were took about a week ago, I'm not sure but it think they might be tree Pipits.

 

[Butty]

Hind claw seems not to be absurdly long so you might well be right. (I am choosing to ignore the lovely fine flank-streaks as this seems to be a rubbish feature.) In my opinion.

 

[Alexander Stöhr]

Hello,

I agree with Butty.
The left bird is a confident Tree Pipit for me. Very good head pattern, smooth warm coloration, short pinkish hind claw (contrasting dark in many (?) Meadow Pipits), and flank streaking finer than breast streaking (yes I agree with you Butty).

Right bird looks also good to me (by gut feeling, trinangular bill with the right colouration), do you have more pictures of it?
Anyway, I cant see anything wrong for a Tree Pipit.

And I hope for more comments. Thanks!

 

[Baldoon57]

If put up another picture of the bird in the second picture , it was feeding on the ground under a oak tree.