Mike Crawley
Emeritus President at Burnage Rugby Club
122. Smew (Mergellus albellus)
No sooner did I finish typing this than I checked my feeder and saw another new bird.Today I went over to the Ohio River which forms the western border of West Virginia. Some birds that are easy there are pretty tricky in this part of the state. Didn’t do as well as I hoped, but I did add three birds to my Year List.
79. American Coot
80. American Herring Gull
81. Peregrine Falcon
Dave
Is the Torry Island pouluation of Tricolored Munia considered a wild in origin established group?(Southern Palm Beach)
108. Purple Martin
109. American Bittern
110. Gray-headed Swamphen
111. Purple Gallinule
112. Sora
113. White-winged Dove
114. Mottled Duck
115. Glossy Ibis
116. Northern Shoveler
117. Egyptian Goose
118. Black-bellied Whistling-Duck
119. Merlin
120. American Wigeon
121. Gadwall
122. Dickcissel
123. Indigo Bunting
124. Blue Grosbeak
125. Tricolored Munia
126. Northern Rough-winged Swallow
127. Tropical Kingbird
128. Vermillion Flycatcher
It's leaning either way, the birds were not found until late last year, but considering the site wasn't heavily birded until recently who knows; now however, the site has become a mini "Patagonia picnic table" with rare birds being reported on a weekly basis, the newest addition is at least 4 American Pipits just today.Is the Torry Island pouluation of Tricolored Munia considered a wild in origin established group?
I think its more that the ABA doesn't entangle themselves into debates on what and what isn't countable once that species is on the checklist. ABA's stance isn't "Now any Tricolored Munia seen in its boundaries is countable", it's "The Tricolored Munia is on the checklist...count it on your own discretion, as we do not evaluate all individual records of rare birds"It's leaning either way, the birds were not found until late last year, but considering the site wasn't heavily birded until recently who knows; now however, the site has become a mini "Patagonia picnic table" with rare birds being reported on a weekly basis, the newest addition is at least 4 American Pipits just today.
But going back to the Munias, the odd part is that the ABA kind of considers them countable since any bird found in Florida is considered a "vagrant" from Cuba.